Monday, January 28, 2013

Midterm


Preliminary Questions
1.       Alexandria Miranda -  amiranda21@student.mtsac.edu
2.       I’ve completed 7 posts
a.       Post 1 – 1/10
b.      Post 2 – 1/14
c.       Post 4 – 1/20
d.      Post 5 – 1/20
e.      Post 6 - 1/21
f.        Post 7-  1/26
g.       Post 8 - 1/27
h.      Response post 1- 1/10
i.         Response post 2-  1/20
j.        Response post 3 – 1/27
3.       Readings completed
a.       Week 1: Religion, Memes
b.      Week 2: Hinduism reading A-G, BBC website on Jainism, Why I don’t Eat Face, and The Sikhs
c.       Week 3: Buddhism on the Big View and BBC website, Taoism by Huston Smith
The only reading I did not fully complete was the Mystics of India. I was sick and ran out of time to complete this lesson.
4.       Films watched
a.       Week 1 : BARAKA, Susan Blackmore’s TED Talk
b.      Week 2: Auto lecture on Hinduism, Huston Smith on Hinduism, The Story of India, John Green Indus Valley Civilization, Intro to Jainism, Why I don’t Eat Faces, Ahisma, Baba Ji explains Jainism, and Congressman Kicinich address to a Jain audience, Mt. Sac Sikh film pt. 1 and 2.
c.       Week 3: The Buddha, Karen Armstrong on the Axial Age, John Green lecture on Chinese Thought, Introduction to Taoism.
5.       I listened to every lecture provided but I didn’t find them particularly helpful in the way I wanted. Each lecture was very informative but they were also very brief. I would have preferred listening to longer lectures with your personal ideas and insights into each religion as well as perhaps more scholarly insight instead of straight facts. I did find the Buddhist lecture helpful though, especially the clarification of the 4 noble truths and the 8 fold path.  I particularly liked the part of the lecture discussing the Buddhist idea of the non-self, and how it’s like a fire flickering away.
6.       Field Trip – My original plan was to attend the Buddhist Temple in Hacienda Heights with a friend who is also interested in Buddhism on Sunday Feb. 2nd. Since learning more about Buddhism in lesson 7, I may change the destination to the Zen center in Hollywood.
7.       Hours
a.       Week 1 – 9 hours
b.      Week 2 – 12 hours
c.       Week 3 – 14 hours
8.       Of all the eastern religions, I identify the most with Buddhism because it speaks about the nature of suffering and how to cease it. I am particularly interested in Zen Buddhism because it also combines elements of Taoism with Buddhist philosophy.  I like both Buddhism and Taoism because there is no God to judge us or tell us right from wrong; instead there is only the truth and the reality we live in. It is up to the person to learn and cultivate wisdom; no one can do it for us. Even though Buddhism does focuses on ending samsara, the insights and truths offered by the Buddha also contribute to living a life without suffering.  The idea of the non-self also makes me drawn to Buddhism. My feelings are that if there is no inner self then I can be whoever I choose without restriction or fear of “losing” myself. The 8 Fold Path is also intriguing to me because it is a proscription for how to live and avoid suffering, and all the tenets can be followed even if one doesn’t want to commit to Buddhism.


Midterm Questions

1A. Reading

The word religion comes from the Latin root religo, which means to bind. The text, Religion, implies that religion binds us to a sense of sacred. Paul Tilich contends that religion is one’s “ultimate concern” meaning the concern of our existence, why are we here, where are we going? Tillich goes further to say that religion is what gives meaning to life and provides a sense of transformation to our inner selves. W. C. Smith believes that religion is a cumulative tradition that has evolved over time to suit the needs of the people. These definitions still do not fully describe what religion is, and for the purpose of this class I believe that Ninian Smart’s definition of a seven dimensional organism best defines what religion is. The first dimension of religion are myths or sacred stories that can either be historical stories embellished with symbolism or purely symbolic stories to represent the history, value and ideals of the religion. Rituals are also very important because these are activities such as prayer or chants that help the adherent connect to the sacred and also have an experiential component that induces transcendent feelings that can be achieved through ritual or spontaneously. The fourth dimension of religion is doctrines, a philosophy or belief system, and the fifth is ethics, moral codes, to help guide the adherent. Religions also have a social aspect where adherents share common values and bond. Finally, the last dimensions of religion are material forms that are important such as sacred objects, texts or temples. Religion can further be classified by whether it is an established religion, a sect or a cult. An established religion is a former sect or cult that has stood the test of time and has adapted to meet the needs it’s followers. While an established religion has low tension with the rest of society, sects and cults have high tension with the rest of society due to their relative newness. Sects are schism groups that break off from established religions either to return to the original teachings of religion, while cults are new religions, or at least new to the geographic area, that are attempting to establish themselves.

There are many different ways to understand and study religion. Religious studies can include theology, religious studies, phenomenology, and sociology of religion, psychology of religion, history of religion and anthropology of religion. These religious studies can be simplified into three categories; antipathy, sympathy and empathy. Antipathy scorns religion and sees it as oppressive while the sympathetic approach assumes the truth of a particular religion and evaluates all other religions as lesser versions of the correct one. An empathetic approach is to view the religion objectively by stepping into the adherents shows to understand their beliefs. Within the empathetic category falls Phenomenology, the objective, descriptive study of religious phenomena. The reading advocates the use of empathy and phenomenology for our class, along with socio-historical analysis. It is through the use of these techniques that we can understand the origins and implications of religion, along with their individual characteristics.

Just as there are many different ways to study religions, there are just as many theories as to the origin of religion. The theological theory is that religion has a transcendent origin; a god/goddess gave spiritual wisdom to various prophets or mystics to be passed down. The psychological theory is that religion springs from our unconscious. Freud argues that religion was formed because of human kind’s unconscious neurosis, while Jung believes religion springs from our collective unconscious which contains a myriad of archetypal images that manifest in our dreams and are expressed through religion. Still yet, sociology contends that religion has social origins. Emile Durkheim believes religion is the personification of the forces of society and Victor Turner says that religion offered a sense of community and equality. Anthropology also offers a theory that religion grew from animism or magic. There is also a biological theory that religion developed because it gave us an evolutionary advantage. This theory is also part of a field of research called evolutionary psychology. According to this theory religion gave humans a sense of meaning and also facilitated group cohesion and social order.

Regardless of which theory is right, religion does serve a social function. George Simmel contends that humans are religious by nature because of three component; nature, which invokes feelings of piety, fate, which provokes existential thought and society, which demands social cohesion. Bryan Wilson elaborates further on the idea of the social function of religion. According to Wilson not only does religion provide hope but it promotes civic service and also gives legitimacy to social and political activities of a civilization. Max Weber and Mark Juergensmeyer, on the other hand, believe that religion is an instrument of social change.

So what is the future of religion? Will religion die out as science and reason become more popular? As stated earlier, religion is a constantly evolving organism adapting to the times and culture. The current trend of religion is set by the baby boomer generation, born between 1946 and 1964. This particular generation is focused on searching out the truth and is shying away from formal, established religions with strict rules and rituals. Instead there is a new emphasis on spirituality, self-realization, and a move away from the traditional Judeo-Christian god. There is also more interest in a pluralistic view of religion and more acceptance of other cultures. Because of all this things, the interest in spirituality, self-realization, and pluralism we are seeing a change in religion.  It isn’t only the emphasis on personal spirituality and self-realization that is changing religion though. There is also a rise in increasing secularization of the world thanks to rational thought and science.  It seems the more science can explain natural phenomena, the less need there is for some people to have religion.

1B. Film

The BARAKA film really inspired me to see the beauty in religion. It’s amazing the amount of time and dedication people to devote to their religions or faiths. The chanting at the jungle temple was beautiful and very interesting how such a large group of people were able to move in unison.  The whirling dervishes were also particularly inspiring; I loved how they whirled while seeming in a deep state of thought. It wasn’t just the worship that was inspiring though. It also amazed me how religion can inspire such great works of art and architecture in the world. The temples and churches were so beautifully and carefully made, one temple seemed to absolutely sparkle. Even though I am not a particularly religious person, it’s really wonderful just to see the joy and beauty religion can bring to people’s lives.  The film inspired me to not just learn about religions objectively but also to see how religion influences a person’s entire life and being. It seems that no matter where you are in the world, religion may have played a big part in your culture.

2A. Reading

Cults are new or alternative religions, it can also refer to a religion that is simply new to a geographic area. Cults typically have high tension within society because cults begin more radical and take time to adapt to the current culture and values. While the word cult may have a negative connotation, for the study of religion it simply means a new religion.  The people who join cults seem to be educated, middle-upper class urbanites that are looking for a sense of community and self-realization or self-help. According to the text there are many Americans who join cults as well, because American tradition focuses on the individual and on a greater acceptance. Some people also leave their current religion for cults; Jewish people turn to cults to fill a void due to their secular environment and Catholics also turn to cults, moving away from the ritual and doctrine heavy church to more self-empowerment. Those who join cults typically learn about new religions at university recruitment events; although only 10% of those who attend these events join and even then seem to not stay more than 2 years. Victor Turner believes that people turn to cults because they are searching for a liminal experience without the structure of more established religions. The accepted academic approach to studying cults is through Phenomenology, objectively observing the religion without value judgments. Objectively studying cults allows the scholar to see the inner workings and the logic of the cults and also creates openness between the scholar and the devotee. Some scholars argue that there are additional research methods are necessary when studying cults such as focusing on the philosophical connections to historical religions, explicitly stating one’s bias and avoiding experiential participation.

Memes are ideas or information that is replicated from person to person, or host to host. Memes can be just about any idea or information, like a new phrase, fashion trend or even advertising. Our brain is the host to memes and they compete to replicate themselves in minds. Memes work in a way similar to genes because memes are competing to replicate in a limited number of hosts; thusly only the most well adapted memes will be able to replicate themselves into a large numbers of hosts. There are certain rules that make a meme successful in its efforts to replicate itself. The first is in the memetic distribution. Memes should not impede the replication of memes and typically encourage others to teach or spread the idea. Typically value related incentives also encourage the replication of memes, particularly ones that incite desire or fear. Finally, meme simplicity is key. Simpler memes do better than more complex ones because they are easier to remember.

Using meme theory, we can see how religions form and how they are able to become so popular. Religions have a simple message that contains what a person may desire and fear, such as heaven and hell. Religions that tend to be more successful are the ones that encourage their adherents to evangelize, or distribute, the religious message. Developmental psychology also plays an important role in the success of memes. A meme can only be successful if it is appropriate to the current stage of consciousness of the host. Stage of consciousness can be determined by age, for instance a prepubescent would not be interested in a sexual meme, or the current culture. Ken Wilber defines three different stages of consciousness: pre-rational, rational and trans-rational. Pre-rational consciousness would be interested in magic or other non-rational ideas, while rational thought involves critical thinking and trans-rational thought also concerns itself with mysticism. In each of these stages, different memes would be more successful depending on the meme content. In this way too, we see how certain religions become more popular depending on the current culture and stage of consciousness experienced by society as a whole.

2B. Film

In her TED talk, Susan Blackmore argues that humans are earth’s Pandoran species because of the two different replicators we have unleashed upon the earth. The first replicator would be genetics and the second would be memes. Genes and memes both are very similar in how they replicate, very much in accordance with the Darwinian theory of evolution. Any information that is varied and selected will produce a design without the need for intelligence. It’s inevitable that in a pool of competition, the genes or memes that can most adapt to the current environment or culture will be selected and passed creating a type of design. Blackmore also argues that information, or replicators, are selfish and will attempt to copy themselves as much as possible regardless of the cost. This isn’t because the information is aware, it is simply the nature of memes to try to replicate as much as possible. The copied information can be our genetic code or it can be other copied information that transmits from person to person. Blackmore points to the concept of earrings as meme or the idea of toilet paper folding as a type of meme.

So why do memes spread? According to Blackmore it isn’t dependent on a meme being truthful or right or even beautiful. Although these qualities may play a part in the successfulness of a meme, a meme will simply try it’s hardest to be copied in as many hosts as possible. There is also a problem in the limited amount of hosts available for the memes to be copied, and with this idea Blackmore segued into the idea that memes played a part in our cultural and physical evolution. Typically, our evolutionary history has been thought to be determined by our genetics but Blackmore argues that memes also played a role in development. Being able to copy information was an advantage to early humans because of the useful information copied, such as building fires or creating language. The concept of memetic drive is the idea that memes have driven us to grow longer brains to contain language, art, music and other information that we copy. As Blackmore says we are the “meme machines.”

3A. Reading
I don’t know.

3B. Film
I don’t know.

4A. Reading

Hinduism is one of the world’s extant religions; it is the third largest world religion with a billion followers. Hinduism is a broad mixture of religious, philosophical and cultural practices and ideas. Hinduism is a unique religion that doesn’t have any one core specific belief or founder, but it can be characterized by a belief in reincarnation, samsara, and the goal of attaining liberation from the cycle of rebirth and death. Hindu’s seek liberation, or moksha, because the cycle of rebirth inherently implies suffering. One’s rebirth is also affected by a person’s karma, or actions. Hinduism is a metafaith that has existed for 10,000 years by evolving and accommodating other cultures.  It began in the Indus River Valley as a mixture of cultures and faiths from the indigenous and migrating populations.

The word Hindu originates from the Sanskrit word for the Indus River, Sindhu which was eventually turned into the Hindu by the Persians. It wasn’t until the 18th century that Hindu became a classification for the religion. The Indus River was a vital part in the history of Hinduism; it was in the Indus River Valley that a complex civilization began to form. The Indus River Valley Civilization was a complex civilization as early as 2500 BCE with elaborate cities made of fired brick and drainage systems and was also the largest political community prior to the formation of the Roman Empire. This civilization had language, agriculture and also art. Physical evidence of this civilization includes images of fertility gods and goddesses, some of which are seated in the familiar lotus position. This indigenous civilization continued until Aryans, from what is now Aryan, migrated to the area between 1700 and 1200 BCE. Historians don’t know if this migration was an invasion by the Aryans or if the Pre-Aryan Indus River Valley civilization was in decline. The Aryans brought the caste system with them, an integral part of Hindu culture and religion, and built cities and minor kingdoms in 6th century BCE. They also brought Sanskrit, the Vedic Scriptures and the idea of polytheism.

Hinduism is a religion that encompasses many different gods, practices and beliefs.  As stated earlier all Hindus believe in samsara and they believe that their karma influences this cycle of death and rebirth until they are able to reach moksha. Dharma, or the ethics and duties of a person, is also an important facet of the faith. There are two Dharmas a person can choose Grinhastha Dharma or Sannyasin Dharma. Grinhastha Dharma is the lay persons form of religion and focuses on four purusharthas, or goals, of life. Kama is the sensual goal of life; Artha is the goal material wealth and prosperity while Dharma is the goal of social duties and obligations in life. Sannyasin Dharma only shares one goal with Grinhastha, the goal of moksha. Sannyasin Dharma is an ascetic life, giving up material things and focusing on the goal of ultimate liberation. Hindus also believe that there are four stages or ashramas to a man’s life. Women were not necessarily included in this idea, because they were considered dependents. The first ashrama is that of a student until the age of 25, the second is the married man’s life where one pursues the kama and artha goals of life, followed by a retreat into the forest as one greys and wrinkles, the third ashrama. The final ashrama is that of a wandering ascetic, working toward moksha.

A Hindus life is also influenced by the caste system, a class system with the darker-skinned people as the lower classes and lighter skinned peoples as rulers and priests. There are four castes the Brahmin, the priest caste, Kshatriyas, warriors and kings, Vaishyas, merchants, landowners and moneylenders and finally the Shudras, or servants. There is also a class of people called untouchables who handle the ritually impure tasks and generally are considered completely outside of the caste system. Hindus believe that one is born into a caste because of their karma and traditionally marry and stay within their class for their entire lives. The caste system defines what type of job a person has, who they marry, and where they live. Within this caste system there are even further distinctions.

In Hinduism there are four different paths, or yogas, to enlightenment. The word yoga means yoke or union, and the purpose of yoga is to join the self, also called the soul or Atman, with Brahmin, the ultimate reality and type of creator god. Yoga is a spiritual discipline and meditation is essential to all forms of yogas.  The first yoga is Bkhati yoga, which is the most popular of all the yogas. This is the path of devotion; adherents approach their chosen ishta devata, or desired divinity, with love and devotion and also repeat the divine name or mantra in an attempt to surrender themselves to their god. Jnana yoga is path of knowledge; however it is not simply knowledge but discernment in the true nature of things. There are three stages of knowing in this yoga. The first is hearing, which means listening to sages and scriptures. The next stage is thinking and becoming hyperaware of one’s thoughts and the processes of those thoughts. The final stage is identifying the enduring part of the self, the same part that is one with Brahman, or the ultimate reality. Raja yoga is the path of meditation and it is also known as the royal road to reintegration. This yoga involves intense meditation with strict postures and breath control to concentrate the mind and begin to control it. This yoga focuses on the inner-self as well and the goal is to achieve a trance state to become one with Brahman. Karma yoga is the path of action. This yoga involves approach god through one’s work and actions and being selfless in these actions as that is the only thing that will take you out of yourself and closer to god and moksha. The type of Hinduism a person chooses to practice is up to them and two Hindu doctrines the Doctrine of Spiritual competence and the Doctrine of the Chosen Deity state that a person’s spiritual practices should correspond to their competency and the deity they choose to worship a deity that fulfills their spiritual needs and cravings.

The scriptures of Hinduism, called shastras, are collections of spiritual laws discovered by sages and saints. There are two types of shastras; Shruti, meaning heard, and Smirti, meaning memorized. Shruti scriptures were created by sages who heard the universal truths and include the Vedas and the Upanishads. The Vedas are the earliest literary record on Indo-Aryan civilization and the original scriptures of India. The Vedas are philosophical maxims that were compiled by 1500 BCE and consist of four books; the Rig Veda, Sama Veda, Yajur Veda, and Artharya Veda. The books are further divided into four parts of hymens, rituals, theologies and philosophies. The Upanishads are another Shruti scripture which contain the fundamental teachings of Hinudism such as the soul, Atman, and the absolute almighty, Brahman. There are 108 existing Upanishads, with 10 being most important, and were composed anywhere from 800-400 BCE. Smiriti scripture is memorized poetry and ethics. These scriptures include the Bhagavad Gita, called Song of the Adorable one, which was composed around 2nd century BCE. This scripture contains theological lessons about God and Life. Ramayana is another popular Hindu scripture. It is an epic story of a royal couple from 4th or 2nd century BCE.

There is some debate on whether or not Hinduism is a monotheistic or polytheistic religion. At the center of Hinduism is the concept of Brahman. Brahman is all at once a God and the ultimate goal and absolute, Brahman is the nature of truth, knowledge and infinity. Brahman is the source of reality and gives structure and meaning to the universe and all the things in it. Brahman is all pervading force in the world so Brahman is also part of the inner self in Hinduism. This is where the word Namaste gets its origin, because Namaste literally means I bow to the divine in you. Hindus recognize that Brahman is part of everyone’s self. In this manner others gods and goddesses are also facets of Brahman and Hinduism allows for thousands of different gods. The three most popular gods are the trinity of Brahma, a creator god different than Brahman, Vishnu, the preserver, and Shiva, the destroyer.

There are six major teachers of Hinduism, three from medieval times and three from modern times. Shankara is the first of these teachers, he traveled across India teaching others and discussing his philosophical ideas. Shankara believed that the world was a temporary illusion; he even denounced the cosmos as an illusion. He thought that only the path of knowledge, or Jnana, woud lead to liberation. Work and devotion were secondary on the path toward moksha. Shankara also believed that Brahman was transcendent and defied categorization. Ramanuga, who lived from 1077-1157, was another philosopher and saint of India. He founded the school of Vishitadvaita (special nondualism). In contrast to Shankara, he taught that the highest ideal was love of God, Bhakti, and that Brahman had attributes. The third medieval teacher was Madhava, who lived 1199-1278. Madhava wrote tracts that established the philosophy of dvaita. He taught that Brahman, the soul and the world have existed separately and eternally and it is only the grace of god, in Krishna form, that humans can escape samsara. The first of the modern teachers was Ramakrishna, who was born in 1888 in South India. Ramakrishna graduated with a master’s degree from Madra Christian College and had an academic and political career. He criticized the caste system as well as customs that degraded women. Ramakrishna attempted to unite eastern and western thought in Hinduism. Aurobindo was a teacher who was born in 1872 who attend Cambridge and became a formal teacher. Aurobindo also had a political career and believed in the non-dual nature of the divine. He also developed a new yoga called integral yoga that is supposed to harmonize the whole being by integrating physical, emotional and spiritual aspects. Aurobindo taught that the world is real and not an illusion. Gandhi is the final teacher, who lived from 1869 to 1948. Gandhi is most well-known for his part in the liberation of India from the British Empire and his belief in non-violence.

4B. Films
The Story of India, by Michael Wood, stated that India is an ancient culture and country that has done the remarkable feat of preserving it’s ancient cultural heritage. The film begins with one of India’s oldest myths of creation. According to this myth, the first humans came from a golden egg laid in the cosmic ocean by the gods. According to science and the film, however, our human ancestors walked out of Africa 70,000 or 80,000 years ago walked around the Arabian Sea into South India. All non-African people can trace their descent back to these ancient migrations to India. The film continues to show how ancient India truly is by delving into the oral traditions and DNA of the peole of South India. Inland from the sea, there is an ancient Brahman family who performs rituals and uses mantras. Some of these mantras are not in any known language although they follow rules and patterns. The people do not necessarily know what they mean, but they have been handed down from generation to generation. In another village, a DNA study was done in search of genetic markers of ancient migrations, the M130 gene. Some of the villagers had the markers of this genetic pool from ancient times. Genetic markers are a more apt way to discern between ancient and current populations unlike language which is only about 10,000 years old anyway, and can be easily adopted.

The film then ventures from the ancient pre-history of India and follows it from the stone age to the agricultural revolution and the rise of cities and civilization. As early as 7,000 BCE there were large villages in the Indus River Valley.  In 1921, the ruins of Harpapa were found and it included evidence of huge citadel walls and of industry, trade and writing. This city begvan 3.500 BCE and at the height of the civilization, 2,900- 1,900 BCE, had a population of 200,000 people. Mahengo Dara was another important city; it appeared to be the capital of an empire that stretched from the Himalayas to the Arabian Sea. Its writings are un-deciphered and after several centuries these cities began to collapse. There are theories that the civilization collapsed because of the shifting of the river and climate change and the civilization shifted eastward following rivers to the Ganghes River plain.

On the Ganghes River plain Indian language and literature began to arise around 1500 BCE. The language of this time was Sanskrit but what was unusual was it was not a spoken language except in the instances of religious scriptures. This language was passed down orally and also was preserved almost perfectly throughout the ages. The Aryans, which means “the civilized or socialized” in Sanskrit where a group of people that migrated to India in 1500 BCE. The Rig Veda tells the story of a tribe moving across India that burned forests and were searching for new lands, the Veda calls these people Aryans. Sanskrit is the language brought by the Aryans and bears a remarkable similarity to Greek and Latin and most linguists agree that the common source for these similarities came from outside India. The Rig Veda also talks of horses, which were not native to India, and suggested the Aryans came from as far away as Turkmenistan. This film provided a lot of insight into the ancient people of India and the beginnings of Hinduism.

The next film was an audio lecture on Hinduism. This film discussed the main tenets of Hinduism, Samsara and Moksha and also talked about how Hinduism is accommodating to other religions because it is not dogmatic and does not have a centralized authority. The lecture also discussed the caste system. Despite the fact that many contemporary Hindus would like to define the caste system as a cultural issue instead of religious one, the caste system has been traditionally linked to the religion. This film also discusses some of the scriptures and goes further in-depth on the Bhagavad Gita, which is a story of two warring families and is a dialogue on the ethics of war.

The next film was Huston Smith discussing the Hindu tradition and the underlying motif of Hinduism, that you can have what you want. Hinduism further defines this idea of what we want with the four goals of life, sensual pleasure, material wealth and success, behaving respectfully and liberation. Smith also discusses the different stages of life in Hinduism and how each stages helps fulfill the goals or wants of a person. Finally he discusses the idea that “there are realms of gold hidden in the depths of our heart.” The most lovely part of Hinduism in my opinion is the idea that that which is the divine is also within us, or the concept of that thou art. 

Finally, in the film on the Indus Valley Civilization, I learned about what defines a civilization in order to better discuss the Indus Valley Civilization. The idea of civilizations is intellectual constructs that only apply to certain social groups and not to other social groups like nomadic tribes or cultures, regardless of the complexity of the social order. The signs of civilization include surplus production, a physical city, specialization of labor and trade. Civilizations are also associated with social stratification, a centralized government and shared values and/or religion. Writing is also associated with civilization. Rivers are also very important to civilizations because the river valleys provide flat lands to produce agriculture and annual nutrient enrichment of farmlands when the river floods. This was my favorite of the last three films because it was fast-paced, entertaining and provided a wealth of information on civilizations and more information about the Indus Valley Civilization.

5A. Reading

The Jain religion is an eastern religion that has no gods or spiritual beings. Although they do venerate perfect souls, Jain’s believe that every soul has the potential for this perfection. The Jain argument for atheism is that an immaterial being cannot create a material a material world. The very essence of Jainism is the concern for the welfare of every being in the universe and for the universe itself. This concern is translated through the belief of Ahisma, or non-violence. Jain’s believe that harm done to others is also harm done to one’s self through the concept of karma. There is the belief that all things have a soul and all souls are equal in the universe.  Because of ahimsa, Jain’s are strict vegetarians and slo do not use any animal products or cloth that may harm an animal. Ahisma also affects their career choice because it is unethical in Jainism to participate in a job that causes harm to the environment, animals or other people. In some ways, Jainism is similar to Hinduism. Jain adherents believe in samsara and believe the quality of their rebirths is determined by their karma. One achieves liberation when one has been freed of all karma. Enlightenment is not the same as liberation though, and one becomes enlightened when freed from all harmful karma, one is delivered when one is free from all karma. In this way, Jainism seems to differ from Hinduism with the idea of harmful karma and non-harmful karma. According to Jainism, karma is a physical substance that is attracted to the soul, or jiva. Karma slowly accumulates and affects events in a person’s current and future life. This accumulation of karma also clouds our judgment and encourages us to engage in more negative behavior. Another belief of Jainism is aparigraha, non-acquisition because possessions are an obstacle to liberation. Monks have virtually no possesions while lay Jains simply try to minimize possessions. Every Jain takes 5 vows of non-violence and not participating in stealing, lying, sexual misconduct, or attachment to worldly things.

Jain’s believe in a physical universe that is governed by cosmic laws. One of these lwas is that nothing can be created or destroyed, it can only change form. Loka is the framework of the universe and exists in space; Loka is finite while space is infinite. The universe is then divided into 5 parts, the supreme abode, the upper world, the middle world (where humans live), the lower world and the base. Everything within the universe falls into 5=6 catergories of substance or astikaya. There is the soul that is eternal and conscious, Dharma is the medium of motion, Adharam is the medium of non-motion, Pudgla is physical matter and what karma is made of, Akasa is space, and Kala is time.

The goal of Jainism is to achieve liberation from samsara which is achieved by removing all karma from the soul. Their religious heroes are called tirthankaras, who are teachers. Mahavira is the most recent tirthankara and also the reformer and populizer of Jainism in its current incarnation. Born in 544 or 590 depending on the source, Mahavira spent 12 years fasting and meditating and eventually reached enlightenment to teach the path to others. It is said that he achieved Moksha. The two main branches of Jainism are Sventamara and Digamara. Theses two branches agree on the basics of Jainism and the 5 vows but disagree on several things. The first are the details on the life of Mahavira, such as when he was born, scriptures, rituals, if monks should wear clothes and the status of women. Digamara is the more ascetic branch of Jainism and believe most Jain scripture was lost during a famine, that rituals should be simple and unadorned and that monks should have no possesions or clothes. Sventamara, on the other hand, believes most of the scriptrues survived, have colorful, adorned temples, and allow monks to wear white clothing, own begging bowls and a small broom to sweep the road as to not step on insects.

There is no founder of Jainism, according to their believes the truth has been revealed by 24 tirthankaras, which means “makes a ford.” Tirthankaras appear to teach others the way to moksha and are simply ordinary souls who reached that satate through an intense practice pf penance, equaniamity and mediation. Each person preaches the basic truths of Jainism but changes the message to accomade to the current age and cultures. There is not a lot of historical evidence for this tirthankaras but that is the belief that has been passed down.

Women hold a unique position in Jainism because the religion promotes equality even though women experience spiritual inequality. The Digambara branch believes women cannot achieve liberation and Svetambara Jainism believes they can. The Digambara argument is that nakedness is essential to liberation and women cannot go naked because it would cause desire in men, women are ashamed of their nakedness, and to prevent any negative consequences of a women being naked. Digambara also believes that women are inherently harmful, himsic, because a women’s menstruation harm’s microorganisms in her body. Another arugement for the reason why women cannot achieve moksha is because it is more difficult for women to break free from attachment due to maternal concerns.

A common custom of Jainism is fasting, especially during holy days and fesitvals. Interestingly enough fasting is done more often done by women. Fasting in Jainism is a form of penance that purifies the mind and body. It is not enough to simply stop eating, one must also remove the deire to eat. There are different types of fasting ranging from complete fasting to only giving up favorite foods. There is also a tradition of santhara, fasting in preparation of feath. Those who undertake this feat are revered and it is considered the ultimate way to expunge karma and achieve liberation. There is some concern, however, for the well-being of elders who may be forced into santhara for the honor it brings families. In addition to these customs, Jinas also take pilgrimages to various holy sites and participate in festivals.

Since Jainism has no god, Jains do not worship to appease a god. Their worship services appear similar to Hindu worship but it is focused on providing discipline so one can concentrate on the ideals of Jainism and cultivate detachment. In addition, worship also provides a social benefit and can help bring spiritual purification. Temple worship appears to be important to lay Jains than to monks; in fact some monks are opposed to temple worship. Jains also pray for inspiration. Mediation is also important to Jains and achieving moksha.

What I found interesting about Jainism is how the religious literature has mostly been lost over time and Jains are unconcerned with this fact. The teachings of Mahavira, the Agamas, contained eternal truth without origin or god. The Agamas, to the Jain, were simply teachings from a wise man and are not considered the origin of their religion. It is also interesting that these scriptures were originally memorized in the first place because monks were not allowed material positions.

Jainism bears a close resemblance to Hinduism in its basic ideas, terms and worship practices. Both Jains and Hindus believe in samsara, karma and moksha. Jainism is also reminds me of Buddhism though with the three Jewels and the 8 fold puja.

5B. Film

The first film, Why I don’t Eat Faces, was about vegetarianism being a moral choice in our current society. Lane argues that since meat eating is a choice, it is a moral issue and we should consider why we eat meat. Lane point to the central nervous system of all animals, including humans, that gives us the capacity to feel pain. It is because of this capacity to feel pain that we should not eat things with faces. The second film was on the Jain belief of Ahisma. Ahisma was created as an ethical system to oppose aggression and Jainism is a religion from over 3,000 years ago that continues to thrive. The third film was Baba Ji explaining Jainism and the concept of non-violence. According to Baba Ji, nonviolence begins with the mind because we are not only a body but also a soul. Although creation and destruction are cycles of nature, humans have not right to destroy for their own needs and desires. It is because of all the violence in the world that there is suffering and that is what we must extinguish. The final film was Congressman Denis Kicinich addressing a Jain audience and praising them for their respect of life, and his own personal belief in vegetarianism and non-violence. The Congressman said that he also doesn’t eat anything with a face but all of god’s creatures are simply striving to live, just like humans.

6A. Reading

It is important to study Sikhism despite a bias against covering it because Sikhism is a major world religion with about twenty million adherents. Sikhism is a larger world religion than Judaism, yet is is a little known religion due to the bias towards studying ancient and non-regional religions. Sikhism, despite the large number of follower, is only 500 years old and found primarily in the Punjab region of Northern India. Sikhism was founded by Guru Nanak but has historical and philosophical roots in the Sant tradition. The Sant tradition dates back to 13th century Southern India and included a diverse selection of teachers, or gurus,  who taught that God was without form and transcendent. Sants practice surat shabad yoga, which refers to the spirit and mystical sound current, a form of meditation. Guru Nanak comes from this Sant tradition. McLeod argues that since Nanak draws from this tradition of Santism, he did not in fact truly found Sikhism.

Sikhs recognize ten gurus who are enlightened beings and manifestations of the divine. This is where Sikhs get their name, because Sikh means disciple and they are the disciples of the gurus. Sikhs espouse the traditional Indian concepts of samsara, karma and the goal of moksha. Unlike Hinduism, Sikhism reject the caste system because all people are equally pure, even women.  Sikhs practice bhakti, or devotion and adoration of God and mediate using the divine name of god as a mantra.


A scholar’s view can challenge a traditional or orthodox view of a religion by seeing past the religious ideals and doctrines and objectively studying a religion and its history. The Sikh religion is particularly influenced more by orthodoxy than actual history. W.H. McLeod challenged the current definition of Sikhism and focused on the historical connections of Sikhism to larger Indian traditions. He contends that the Sant tradition as well as the philosophy and mysticism of Sikhism are directly related to historical Indian traditions. The current incarnation of Sikhism comes from a 19th century revivalist movement that was meant to unify the Sikh culture and Idneity when it was threatened with absorption into the larger Hindu community. Sikhism was originally a religion of evolving traditions and rituals and changed into a non-evolving tradition that proscribed how to dress, rituals, and ethics. Some Sikh scholars deny that the orthodox tradition and history is a new addition despite the historical evidence.


6A. Film

In the online film by Mt. SAC on Sikhism I learned about the Sikh religion and its adherents. Sikhism is practiced by over 300,000 Americans. Male Sikhs have long unshorned hair that is covered with a turban and an uncut beard is typically identifying a male Sikh. Women follow similar rules of dress, but do not wear a scarf. Sikhism was founded by Guru Nanak who rejected the caste system by saying that all people, women and men, are equal and thus not subject to inferior or superior classes. Nanak also defined God as universal god without a male or female gender. Nanak also discussed the importance of tolerance for all cultures and faith. Nanak was followed by 9 other gurus that greatly influenced the Sikh religion.  Unlike other Indian religions, the Sikh religion is a monotheistic religion with one all-encompassing god. Sikh’s are pervasive throughout American society, over 25% of California farmlands are owned by Sikhs. The Sikh focus on equality has led many temples to create soup kitchens to feed people for free.

7A. Reading

The Buddha was born as Siddhartha Gautama in 563 BCE to the ruler of the Sakya tribe, King Suddhodana near the Nepal/India border. It was predicted before Siddhartha was born that he would become either a universal monarch or great spiritual leader, a Buddha. Buddha means one who has supreme knowledge. Siddhartha’s mother died 7 days after his birth and he was raised in a palace by his aunt. Very early on Siddhartha showed a proclivity towards the spiritual side of life, developing his first Jahana, or meditative absorption at a ploughing ceremony. When he is 16 years old, Siddhartha marries his cousin Princess Yasodhara and they spent 13 years together, eventually conceiving a song together. Depite the luxury and wealth that Siddhartha lives in and despite having a wife and son, Siddhartha becomes unsatisfied with his life, seeing everything as only a fleeting pleasure. To combat his woes, he goes on a chariot ride and uncovers what has been hidden from him in his palace. He first sees an old man, then a sick man, a dead man being cremated and a sadhu, or holy man. Upon coming to the realization that everyone, including himself, will age, sicken and die he decides to find a way to avoid the suffering. Siddhartha gives up his life as a prince, shaves his hair and becomes a beggar in search of the ultimate truth. He became the disciple of various Brahmin teachers and eventually attracts his own disciples. Soon however, Siddhartha grows disillusioned with the rigid caste system, ascetism and religious doctrines of the Brahmin. He gives up the ascetic life and loses his disciples as a consequence. Despite all this, Siddhartha continues searching through meditation for the ultimate truth.  In April or May of 538 BCE Siddhartha teaches his great enlightenment under a Bodhi Tree and became a fully realized Buddha at age 35. He then spends his time teaching and converting people to Buddhism. In his first sermon one disciple immediately becomes an arhat, enlightened one, and the sermon began the Sangha, Buddhist order. Siddhartha even converts his father’s court to his path of enlightenment, and ordains his aunt as the first female Sangha.

The enlightenment the Buddha received came in the form of the Four Noble Truths. The First Noble Truth is all life is duhkka, suffering. The Buddha believed that since human nature and the world are imperfect human beings are bound to suffer. Whether it’s from physical illness, emotional distress, or death it is inevitable that one will experience pain. Since our world is also temporary, even positive emotions, feelings or situations are bound to pass and leave us suffering. The Second Noble truth is that the origin of suffering is attachment. Dukkha is caused by Tahna. Our attachment to temporary feelings, objects and people is what causes the suffering. Our “craving and clinging” to these things causes suffering because these things are temporary. Even attachment to the self creates suffering since the self is an illusion. The Third Noble Truth is that we can stop Duhkka by stopping Tahna. The cessation of suffering is attaible through Nirdoha, the unmaking of sensual cravings and attachments. Buddhists believe that through dispassion that suffering may be removed. The Fourth Noble Truth is the path to the cessation of suffering. This path is through the middle way, a path that avoids both extreme hedonism and extreme asceticism. According to Buddhism any other path leads to “wandering on the wheel of becoming.” This path towards enlightenment may take may lifetimes and it subject to karmic conditioning.
The 8 Fold Path is then the way to live in the search for enlightenment and Nirvana. The first step is Right view, being able to see life and reality for what it truly is. This step is first undertook with the realization of the four noble truths and continues with the complete understanding of the true nature of reality. The second step is Right Intention which includes resisting desire, resisting anger and aversion and acting harmlessly. The next step is Right Speech which means to abstain from false speech, slanderous speech, harsh words and idle chatter. Right Action follows this step along the path. To have Right Action is to abstain from harming sentient beings, taking what is not freely given and sexual misconduct. Following this is Right Livelihood; which means to refrain from jobs or careers that involve dealing with weapons, living beings, intoxicants and poisons. The next step is Right Effort; this means being able to control ones emotional states and avoid unwholesome states and encouraging wholesome states. The next step is Right Mindfulness. Right Mindfulness is to be aware and become fully aware through contemplation of the body, feelings, mind and phenomena. Right Concentration is the last step and this step involves being able to concentrate fully on object or idea with the entire mind. Right Concentration can only be attained through Meditation. In addition to the 4 Noble Truths and the 8 Fold path, there are several main precepts Buddhists follow. These precepts are more like recommendations for ethical conduct rather than strict rules. In Buddhism it is more important to have the right intention than adhere to strict rules. Some Buddhists follow 227 precepts but the first 5 are mandatory for every Buddhist. A Buddhist abstains from harming living things, taking things not freely given, sexual misconduct, false speech, and intoxicating drinks or drugs that cause heedlessness.

Buddhism shares many of the same Indian concepts as Hinduism and Jainism. They believe in Samsara, the wheel of life, and in Karma. A Buddhist’s ultimate goal is moksha. The difference though is Buddhism is an atheistic religion with no God. Buddhism also does not believe in the soul or self. This is an illusion, according to Buddhism. Humans are wrongly attributing consciousness and perception of the mind and body with the self. There is self though, because everything is constantly changing and there is no fixed idea of the self.

Buddhism can be divided into 2 main traditions, Theravada and Mahayana Buddhism. Within these two traditions are further subdivisions based off the regional cultures. Theravada Buddhism is called “Southern Buddhism” because it is practiced in the Southeast Asian countries of Sri Lanka, Cambodia, Thailand, Laos and Burma. Theravada means “the doctrine of the elders.” This school believes they are closest to the original teaching of Buddha, but are not fundamentalists. The teachings of Buddha are simply tools to help people understand the truth. The Buddha was also simply a man who was able to awaken himself, and each person is responsible for their own enlightenment through their own efforts. Enlightenment is the goal and the monk life is also the ideal way to live. Theravada has two different types of meditation Samatha, calming meditation, and Vipassan, insightful meditation. Mahayana Buddhism is popular in Tibet, China, Taiwan, Japan, Korea, and Mongolia. Mahayana Buddhism isn’t a single tradition but a collect of traditions including Zen, Pure Land and Tibetan. This tradition believes in the Trikaya, the 3 bodies of Buddha. The first body is transcendent, the second his Buddha’s body of bliss, and the third is Buddha’s early body. The goal and ideal life of this Buddhist tradition is to become a Buddhist Bodhisattva, an enlightened being free from suffering.  While Mahayana has some of same basic teachings as Theravada it also uses different methods. For example, Pure Land Buddhism uses chanting of the name Amitabha Buddha to reach the Pure Land, a plane of consciousness that makes it easier to attain Nirvana. Zen Buddhism of is a mixture of Mahayana Buddhism and Taoism focused more on living life directly and fully. Korean Zen and Nichiren Buddhism are also Buddhist traditions tied closely to their country of origin, Korea and Japan respectively. Tibetan Buddhism is perhaps the most well-known Buddhism, thanks to their spiritual leader the Dali Lama. This school of thought combines Mahayana Buddhism with Tantric, Shamanic and an ancient Tibetan religion called Bon. It may be considered part of the Vajrayana Buddhist Tradition. The Dali Lama is a spiritual teacher and Tibetan Buddhism emphasizes the relationship between life and death, and the impermanence of things. This Buddhism places great importance on rituals and symbolism.

Buddhist philosophy holds that existence is a tragedy because it is subject to impermanence, suffering and uncertainty. These three tilakhanas, or signs of existence, are because we are reborn over and over again, which causes suffering. It is impermanent and uncertain because no state or thing lasts forever; and also because our experiences cannot be defined. A person that is on the wheel of becoming can be born into one of six realms. These realms are the realm of the gods (devas) realm of humanity, realm of the Titans or angry gods(asuras) realm of the hungry ghosts (pretas), the animal realm, and hell. The first two realms are the ones that are desirable to be reborn into, while the last three realms inhabitants have a defect, for example the hungry ghosts suffer from greed. These realms are interlinked in some manner and people may experience these realms without having to be reborn by experiencing negative or positive emotions or states according to the BBC website. Another interesting aspect of Buddhism is their ethics on abortion and contraception. One of the precepts of Buddhism is to refrain from harming another living being, so it is natural to assume that Buddhism doesn’t advocate abortion. Buddhist belief is that life and rebirth begins at conception and it is bad karma to cause a rebirth so quickly after being given life. However, Buddhism allows the use on contraception as long as it is a preventative method and not one that destroys the embryo.

7B. Film

The Buddha film began with the myth of the Buddha’s birth. The mother of Siddhartha had a dream of a beautiful white elephant that jumped into her side. It was said that this dream was a foretelling of her son who would be a great ruler or spiritual leader. When the Buddha was born he emerged from her side. Unfortunately, the Buddha’s mother died 7 days after her birth. Even if this myth is simply a myth, the story of Buddha’s life and all the things he did is an archetypal story that helps others on their path to enlightenment; it is a means to an end. There are many different stories of Buddha, each tradition and culture have their own myths and legends. The film quotes the Buddha saying, “where you see me you will see th teaching, where you see the teachings you will see me.” Buddhism teaches one how to see the joy in life and find a way to stop the suffering. The film on the Buddha discusses how Buddhism is such a powerful religion. It touches on something that is both very personal and yet we share it with everyone. The Buddha said, “The world is full of pain and sorrow, but I have found a serenity that you can find too.” The truth of it is that everyone suffers, no matter what we do to prevent it we all will suffer there ravages of time, disease and loss. The Buddha began as man dissatisfied with his life of pleasure travelled through his kingdom and saw suffering. The Buddha himself suffered at an early age by the loss of his mother, one of the poets on the film said “suffering on a primitive level is what makes a Buddha.” In attempts to relieve this suffering, the Buddha turned to a life of asceticism because there is “no knowledge without sacrifice.” Even this does not ease the Buddha’s suffering fully. It is then he learned that suffering was endless and he needed to find a way out, or to become enlightened.

The Axial age occurred between 900-200 BCE. All major world traditions have roots in this time period because of the common perspectives and experiences during this time period. During this time, regions experienced violence along with the development of iron weapons and deadlier warfare. It was during this time that large states depended on coercion to survive, using armies and police forces to control the labor and population. The areas of civilization also saw in increase in aggressive capitalism and created a catalyst for religious change. The world religions that sprung up during this time period were searching for an alternative to the violence. The sages and wise men of these new religions were not interested in metaphysics or doctrines but on how to divest the self to get rid of the negative human qualities of ego, greed, hatred and envy. All the religions had the same core principle of compassion for other living beings. Buddhism fits deftly into this time period because it is a religion that focuses on removing the self and cultivating goodwill and compassion for all things. Buddhism is not only a religion of compassion but of equality as well.

8A. Reading

Tao means path or way, and in the Taoist religion there are three different ways this “path or way” may be understood. The first is the way of ultimate reality. This meaning of Tao cannot be understood or perceived because it is a transcendent idea of reality. The second way is the way of the universe. This Tao is more spirit than matter, it is what gives nature it’s order. According to the reading this Tao is immanent; it is the driving force in all of nature and life. It fills the flesh and gives meaning and truth to all things. The third Tao is the way of human life. This way is the Tao that we are most familiar with; it is how we live and breathe and how we attempt to gain harmony with the world.

In addition to three paths of Tao there are three schools of thought on Taoism that focus on the te, power, that flows through the cosmos and all human beings. The first school of Tao, Philosophical Tao, focuses on the efficient use of te. This school of thought is a relatively unorganized group that is focused more on reflection on self-help than any particular actions or rituals. Philosophical Tao is an attitude toward life that seeks to conserve life’s vitality by reducing friction and conflict that drains away te. This Tao is the way of wisdom because to live wisely, according to Taoists, is to conserve life’s energy and spend it wisely. The second school of Tao is Yoga Tao. This is a vitalizing Tao that seeks to increase the supply of Te. This school has long held adherents who sought immortality and attempted experiments in eating, sexual activity and breathing to increase and prolong the life giving power. It is from this Tao that come’s the idea of Ch’i, which literally means breath but it Taoism refers to vital energy or power that courses through a person. T’ai Chi Chuan is an exercise that is a combination of calisthenics, dance, meditation and martial arts that draws ch’i from the universe and dislodges blocked Ch’i  in the body. A yoga very similar to Hindu Raja yoga is also practiced, Tao yoga borrows many of the posture and concentration techniques offered by Raja yoga. It is through meditation that this Tao seeks to find balance in one’s self and in one’s community. Finally, religious Tao is a mixture of Taoism and Chinese folk religion. It uses rituals that seem to have a magical effect to harness higher powers to benefit a person and their community.

Despite the fact there are three different school of Tao, some adherents are involved in all 3 schools because each tradition is not sharply defined. There are Taoist values that are honored throughout each tao such as wu wei. Wu wei literally means inaction, but to Taoists it means pure effectiveness and creative quietude, or supreme activity and supreme relaxation. In order to be truly effective one must stop the conscious mind, relax and let go to experience creativity and spontaneity. A Taoist saying is “the way to do is to be.” This means to let go and be like the water, effortlessly flowing and changing the world around it without having to struggle. Taoist values also include humility, harmony with nature, non-violence and simplicity. Even Tao temples blend in with the surrounding environment to create harmony with the world around them. Tao also values the dualistic nature of the world, represented best by the yin yang symbol.  

8B. Film

Video one discusses Chinese thought shaped the way their stories were told from 150 BCE until 1911 CE. They were one of the first people to write history but it is a problem because how their histories are told is influenced by their ideals and expectations of what history should be. China created the Mandate of Heaven to explain why dynasties rose and fall during Chinese history. According to the Mandate of Heaven, Heaven gives a mandate to good rulers and takes away the power from rulers who are not moral or upright. The morals were set by Confucian principles of social harmony, education, and structure and order as well upright behavior. There are five key relationships in Confucianism; the most important relationship being one of filial piety. This regards honoring one’s father and a father honoring one’s son through discipline, education and care.  These Confucian ideals greatly influenced the historical records of Chinese history.

The second video discusses Taoism and what the goal of Taoism is. Taoism seeks a solution to the lifelessness that is created by living in a society that is constrained by etiquette, rituals and other people’s expectations, an ant-thesis to the strict and formal traditions of Confucianism. To flourish and thrive in the world, it is important to live a life that spontaneous, natural and free. It is important to note though, that living spontaneously is to not live impulsively, instead it means to live fully and to simply be. Taoism is attractive to people in a stable society because it begins to give meaning and simplicity to a potentially complex life. Taoism is focused on the unlearning of the self to find what is truly pure and good.


No comments:

Post a Comment